Delivering Solutions to Families for 30 years.

Errors On Wills Can Cause Years of Complications

July 02, 2021  |   Posted by :   |   Blog

The importance of a professionally drawn-up will that has been overseen and checked by a solicitor just cannot be overstated. An improperly-drafted will can cause as much stress and complication as not having a will at all. Seemingly minor errors can lead to major issues that result in unnecessary costs, lengthy disputes, and even long-term family rifts.

One such example is the will of Mark Butler, who died of cancer in 2007 at the age of 44. A missing signature on his will ended up causing decades of disagreement and created a rift between his remaining family that has left them estranged.

After Mark’s death it quickly became apparent that there was an issue with his will. His father, Gerald, who was the executor of Mark’s estate, noticed it had not been signed properly. Mark’s will had been drafted while he was in palliative care and not only was it missing a signature but it had only been witnessed by one person rather than the required two and some parts had been crossed out. All these issues rendered the will invalid and since there was no earlier version to fall back on, Mark’s estate came under intestacy laws.

Mark ran a corporate hospitality business and had a sizeable estate, but because of the errors in his will his intentions for distributing his assets after he passed were unable to be followed according to the instructions he had set out. He had spoken to his family his final wishes after he was diagnosed with cancer and one his sisters, Charlotte, believed that he planned to leave her a substantial gift in his will, and that their sister Jane was named as a potential guardian to his two children. However, these details were among those that had been struck out, and since the will was no longer valid, could not be taken into account, regardless.

The missing signature subsequently left Charlotte with no inheritance and Mark’s wife Taryn needing to pursue a claim against her children to avoid inheritance tax. At the time, in 2007, under intestacy laws, a surviving spouse was eligible for £125,000 from an estate—a figure that has been increased to £270,000 today, along with half of the rest of its value. The remainder automatically went to Mark’s children, meaning they would have to pay inheritance tax – something that could have been avoided had it been passed directly to Taryn.

Taryn therefore made an unusual claim to recover money from her children’s inheritance in an attempt to reduce their tax bill. Her argument was that Mark had believed that his will was correct and valid, and he wanted to leave her the significant assets of their £1.5 million home in Notting Hill and a share of his business.

Mark’s sister Charlotte, however, claims that she was cut off from Mark’s family during the dispute, which took place in private via the court of protection. Charlotte says that she attempted to contact Taryn about the will and related matters several times without success. The last time Charlotte and her parents saw Taryn and Mark’s children was at the wake in 2007. Charlotte says she does not even know where his ashes are and that the whole ordeal has been particularly hard on her parents.

“It was an awful thing for them to see the family ripped apart. It’s very painful to have no relationship with Mark’s children now at all. We feel it would be doing the right thing by Mark to have a connection with them, and it doesn’t seem right for any kids not to know their grandparents.

“We know the kids are safe and happy through hearsay. I don’t know if it’s possible to have a relationship with them. My aim is not to chase them because it would quite frankly be too difficult.”

Charlotte has since retrained in wills and inheritance law to highlight the importance of having a properly-prepared will:

“I hound people. I ask, ‘Why aren’t you signing?’ Improperly signed wills cause so much heartache.” 

For a will to be valid, it must be signed by the donor in the presence of two witnesses who must be over the age of 18, of sound mind, and cannot be beneficiaries or spouses of beneficiaries. The will must also be signed by both witnesses.

Since January 2020 it has been legal for wills to be witnessed remotely due to social distancing rules, however this should remain a last resort, with physical witnessing being preferable so long as it is safe to do so.

A will should contain clear information about how and to whom you would like to bequeath your estate, including any gifts to loved ones or charities, and who you would like to appoint as guardians of any dependent children. You will need to appoint an executor (or several) to manage probate arrangements. And if you make amendments or update your will, it’s important to date each version so that it’s clear which is the most recent.

If you die without a valid will, your estate will be dealt with under intestacy laws, which—as seen above—can lead to very different consequences than you may have intended, potentially even causing disagreements between your loved ones. Therefore it’s vital to have an up-to-date, professional will, prepared by an experienced solicitor. Your solicitor will be able to make sure that there are no errors or omissions and ensure that your wishes are followed to the letter, making things as easy as possible for your family during an already upsetting time.

For more information on making a will, read our many blogs on the subject or get in touch with our Wills & Probate team at Frances Lindsay & Co to speak to one of our friendly family lawyers.

To Top
Close

Need assistance? Enter your details below and we'll contact you to discuss your requirements.