Delivering Solutions to Families for 30 years.

What happens to your pet when it comes to divorce?

September 01, 2021  |   Posted by :   |   Blog

The pandemic has seen a boom in pet ownership with approximately 3.2 million UK households welcoming a new pet into their home since the first lockdown in March 2020. As loving pet owners ourselves, we know how much joy and comfort they can bring to a family—but as family lawyers, we also know how tricky it can be to decide what happens to a beloved pet after divorce.

According to a 2014 study by the Blue Cross, a quarter of all UK divorces involved disputes over pets, and with the sharp increase in animal ownership over the past year this issue could become even more common among divorcing couples.

Most people consider their pet as a member of their family, but unfortunately under current family law rules in England and Wales pets are treated as ‘chattels’, which mean they are deemed as possessions rather than the fur-babies you may see them as. Of course, a living, breathing animal is nothing like your other chattels – it’s unlikely you have such a strong bond with your sofa, book collection or car – and there’s likely to be a lot more emotion involved when it comes to sorting out post-divorce pet ownership than who gets to keep the crockery.

There are calls to increase the rights of pets when it comes to family law, not only to take into consideration the emotional distress of losing contact with a beloved pet but also to ensure that the animal’s welfare and living environment are protected. For example, in California, the court can assign sole or joint ownership of a pet and enter an order that requires whoever keeps the animal provides adequate care.

However, as it stands, our fluffy (and feathered/finned) friends are generally given very little consideration by the courts, unless ownership becomes a sticking point that results in protracted proceedings.

So how do you figure out who gets to keep the dog/cat/budgie/hamster/goldfish when it comes to divorce?

Firstly, as with almost everything to do with separation, the best course of action is to try to discuss the situation and negotiate directly with your spouse. If you still can’t agree, seeking a third party opinion via mediation can be a helpful next step. If you are already working with a solicitor for other aspects of dispute resolution you may be able to discuss your pet-related problems as part of these negotiations, but it’s generally unadvisable to take pet ownership disputes to court unless absolutely necessary.

When determining who should retain ownership of a pet, you might want to take the following into consideration:

  • Did one of you own the pet before your relationship or did it join your family after you got together?
  • Who pays for the pet’s food, vet bills, insurance and general upkeep? Are these costs feasible for either of you on your post-divorce budget?
  • Who does the majority of the pet’s care? Eg: if one of you works long hours it may not be fair for them to have responsibility for an animal that needs companionship.
  • Do you have children who are strongly attached to the pet? In which case, would it be better for the pet to stay in the family home with the children?

Answering these questions honestly will probably give you a better idea of how to proceed, difficult though it may be. But sole ownership isn’t the only solution… Couples with several pets sometimes agree to take one or more each so both are left with an animal companion.

And some couples are able to agree on a form of ‘shared custody’ in which each of them continues to spend time with their pet—for example: one person keeps the dog at their home most of the time but the other walks it regularly. It’s worth noting, however, that ongoing shared access to a pet can become complicated when it comes to schedules, future relationships, and ongoing disputes. This kind of agreement really relies on amicable communication between a separated couple, but perhaps it’s a good starting point for an overall collaborative approach to divorce!

There is one final thing that could help avoid disputes over pets during divorce: the ‘pet-nup’. Similar to a pre-nup or cohabitation agreement, a pet-nup is a pre-emptive agreement that sets out your intentions for the care and ownership of your pet/s should you separate in the future. While the law does not currently recognise pre-nups as legally binding, family law professionals are still likely to take such agreements into account if there is a dispute.

Animals can and do outlive marriages—the average lifespan of a cat or dog is 10+ years—and deciding who gets to keep a pet is often a real sticking point during separation negotiations. For more advice on pet-nups, divorce, mediation or any other aspect of dispute resolution, get in touch with our family law team at Frances Lindsay & Co. We’re pet-lovers too, and we understand how important animal companions can be!

To Top
Close

Need assistance? Enter your details below and we'll contact you to discuss your requirements.