When a marriage ends in divorce, dividing finances can be one of the most challenging aspects, especially when one or both partners have served in the armed forces.
Army pensions are a valuable asset and will be considered in negotiating a financial settlement as part of the ‘matrimonial pot’.
Understanding how military pensions are treated in divorce proceedings is essential for ensuring a fair and informed outcome.
How Are Military Pensions Valued?
Army pensions are valued using a Cash Equivalent Value (CEV), which is provided by the pension scheme administrator.
For armed forces pensions, this would typically be the Veterans UK (formerly SPVA). The CEV represents the notional lump sum that would be needed to provide the benefits due under the pension.
An updated CEV is an essential requirement before considering sharing pensions and particularly in light of the McCloud Judgement, in which public sector CEVs were revalued to avoid discrimination amongst scheme members.
Military pensions (Defined Benefit Schemes) are often more generous than typical workplace pensions (Defined Contribution Schemes), particularly due to benefits such as the ability to draw down at an earlier age (scheme specific) and inflation protection. Therefore, even if the CEV seems low, the true value of the pension might be higher based upon the income the scheme produces in retirement.
Pension Sharing vs Offsetting
There are three main ways to deal with a military pension in divorce, as follows:
- Pension Sharing Order – The pension scheme is instructed to transfer a percentage (to two decimal places) to the non-member spouses’ own pension pot or internally within the scheme – the latter is generally preferrable. The aim is typically to produce equality of income in retirement.
- Pension Attachment Order – The non-member spouse receives an agreed amount of the member spouse’s pension income upon retirement. There are downsides to this arrangement however, including that the non-member spouse will not receive income until the member spouse retires. In addition, pension income will be lost on the death of the member spouse or if the non-member spouse remarries.
- Pension Offsetting – In this method, the value of the pension is offset against other assets, such as the family home. For example, one spouse might keep more of the house while the other retains full pension benefits.
Pension on Divorce Expert (PODE)
When dealing with Defined Benefit Schemes and particularly Armed Forces Pension Schemes, instructing a PODE is essential to consider how the totality of the pension pot (across both parties) can be shared to equalise income in retirement. Otherwise, pension sharing can lead to unintended and unforeseen outcomes. A Judge upon considering a ‘draft’ financial remedies order, may also wish to see evidence of the parties having taken expert advice regarding pension sharing.
The value of a pension is principally to produce an income in retirement and likely when the parties are no longer in receipt of income from employment, which can be many years after a financial settlement.
Armed Forces Pensions are complicated and the importance of seeking the advice of as PODE cannot be overstated. Be sure to consider your choice of PODE carefully to ensure that they understand the specific and nuanced complexities of Armed Forces Pensions.
Early Departure Payments
Armed Forces Pensions can also provide for an Early Departure Payments (EDP) – a feature of the 05/15 schemes only. This includes a tax-free lump sum and regular income payments made from the date at which the member leaves service (if after their 40th birthday and provided certain criteria) until retirement.
It should be noted that EDPs are not considered pension rights by the scheme and are not included in the CEV.
This may therefore need to be addressed by way of periodical payments or an adjustment to pension sharing based upon the respective incomes of the party’s following a financial settlement.
Key Considerations
- Armed Forces Pension Schemes (AFPS) vary depending on the year of service (e.g. AFPS 75, AFPS 05, AFPS 15). Each scheme has different rules (including pension ages) and benefits, which must be understood during settlement negotiations.
- Consider contacting the Forces Pension Society (https://forcespensionsociety.org/) who provide support, education and guidance for scheme members.
- Legal advice and pension actuaries are often essential to ensure fairness, especially where complex calculations are required and when different schemes confer different benefits and provide varying income levels in retirement.
Final Thoughts
Armed Forces Pensions are valuable assets. In a financial remedy you only get ‘one bite of the cherry’. Taking the time to seek legal and financial/actuarial advice is likely to lead to a fair and informed outcome, which will place the parties in the best possible position upon drawing down their pension(s) in retirement.
