Delivering Solutions to Families for 30 years.

Non Court Dispute Resolution – The Private FDR

August 15, 2024  |   Posted by :   |   Divorce

If you are a regular reader of our blogs you will recall that we had two blogs at the end of last year about mediation and the delays in the courts.

This is a more in-depth explanation of new rules and Alternative Dispute resolution, now rather snappily called NCDR or Non-Court Dispute Resolution.

The courts have finally caught up with the real world and have made it (not quite) mandatory to find a solution outside the court system if at all possible. As of 29 April 2024, the new rules require every possible attempt to resolve issues by NCDR before resorting to the court. It’s not mandatory, but if you don’t try to keep it out of court for no good reason, then the court can penalise you with a costs order.

It is also a requirement before every hearing to provide the court with an update on what NCDR has been attempted.

Let me say here if you have a good reason then don’t panic. We can talk about that.

In this series of blogs we look at the various types of NCDR. Today we look at The Private FDR.

The Private FDR

A Financial Dispute Resolution will eventually be listed by the court if you cannot reach an agreement. It is important to know that most cases settle at or soon after FDR. So what is an FDR? An FDR is the second court hearing, which you will be required to attend if you can’t settle. The next hearing will be a final hearing, sometimes referred to as a trial. An FDR is a very useful resource and most cases settle at or shortly after FDR.

However, currently getting the court to list an FDR may be 12+ months ahead. This means that not only do you have to wait but all the documents you have already provided. Valuations, pension information, and expert reports will need updating and that is extremely costly. Alternatively, you can consider private FDR, which has the advantage of being able to choose the location, ‘judge’ and timing. Yes, you have to pay for the judge but it is not hugely expensive if you compare it to the cost of updating all your financial disclosure. You have the advantage of a judge who doesn’t have 5 cases listed at the same time and has time to read all the appropriate documents so has a good handle on your case. You have a pleasant environment usually with tea, coffee, biscuits and sometimes sandwiches. This sounds like a minor benefit but if you are to spend the day negotiating it is incredibly important to have somewhere comfortable to sit and privacy for the lawyers to speak to each other.

But what is an FDR? This is a hearing where each party puts their case to the court. Neither party gives evidence in person and it is unlikely that you will be asked to speak, so you can relax and no decision can be made without your agreement. The judge having heard what everyone has to say and read all the documents will give an ‘indication’ of what he/she believes using their knowledge and experience would be the outcome if the case was heard at a full hearing.

Pros:

A private FDR avoids delays and can be less costly than a court-based FDR. You have a choice of Judge

The judge has time to review and consider all the documentary evidence and the case summaries as put forward by your lawyers.

You have a decent environment in which to spend your day negotiating.

All together, this assists a settled agreement.

Cons:

There are a few cons to a private FDR. Some complain of the additional cost but overall it is unlikely to be more costly and can assist in disposing of the matter for less than it would cost to go to court.

If all else fails and the idea of waiting 2+ years for a final hearing makes you queasy, then you should consider Arbitration, and we’ll talk about that next time.


The other articles in this series:

To Top
Close

Need assistance? Enter your details below and we'll contact you to discuss your requirements.