Delivering Solutions to Families for 30 years.

Who gets the dog, cat, tropical fish, lizard?

October 11, 2022  |   Posted by :   |   Notes from the desk

Picture the scene. You and your ex together with a small crowd of lawyers are sitting in the lobby of a rather unpleasant court building surrounded by dirty coffee cups and empty water bottles.  You are all feeling somewhat relieved that after  months of negotiations, a few court hearings and thousands of pieces paper that have incurred eye watering costs you  have agreed as to who is to have:

  • The Family House
  • The Holiday Home
  • The Mercedes
  • The BMW
  • The Tag Heur and the Gentleman’s Rolex
  • The diamond tennis bracelet and the ladies diamond Rolex
  • The second blue sofa from the conservatory

And let’s not forget about the children and where they are to live. All thankfully agreed.

But wait there’s more…….

What about Mabel and Olive you say? Your lawyer is confused. Are these two more children you didn’t tell her about? No, no, no, but they are an important part of the family. Mabel is a 5 year old cocker spaniel and Olive is a 2 year old tabby cat that wandered into the house one day and never left. Who are they to go with? You want to keep them with you. Your ex wants them with them. What to do?

Your lawyers who moments before had been dreaming of a cold glass of pinot Gris or a pint of regular sigh and restart talks. These talks are pretty close to a meeting of the G7 until things get nasty then they become more like peace talks between Russia and Ukraine.

Your ex’s lawyer proposes Olive and Mabel live with your ex and you have them every other weekend and one night in the week. That’s more than you see the children. That’s not going to work for you apparently. You suggest the other way round. This is turned down by your ex. So it goes on for hour after hour and your costs are rising minute by minute. The lawyers see their restorative potions rapidly becoming a mere figment of their imagination. There is nothing else to do but to go back and see the judge.

You sit there horrified as the judge calls your beloved pets chattels. Chattels? They are not things they are part of the family. While contemplating this you can hear the judge drone on somewhere far away about how he must consider them chattels and can simply give them to one or other of you, or one of you can have the cat, the other the dog. He suggests you go and discuss this outside his court and preferably come to an agreement because he has had a long day and neither of you are going to like his judgement. This is all to horrifying to contemplate. You tell your lawyer to put an end to this and get you out of there.

Outside the court, you and your ex are both so traumatised by the experience of having Mabel and Olive referred to as chattels that you come to an arrangement if not amicable at least workable for both of you.

And that is who gets the dog, the cat, the tropical fish, the lizard or the hamster. There is no right or wrong and there is no rule. You must find a middle ground and come to an agreement because you absolutely will not like what a court is going to do.

As a thought for those of you arguing about your fur friends or even the tropical fish, try not to. That scenario could easily have cost £5000 or more.


Need help or advice with divorce, separation, arbitration or any other areas of family law? Frances Lindsay and Co take the weight off your shoulders – email us at enquiries@franceslindsay.co.uk or phone 01628 634 667

To Top
Close

Need assistance? Enter your details below and we'll contact you to discuss your requirements.