If you are a regular reader of our blogs you will recall that we had two blogs at the end of last year about mediation and the delays in the courts.
This is a more in-depth explanation of new rules and Alternative Dispute resolution, now rather snappily called NCDR or Non-Court Dispute Resolution.
The courts have finally caught up with the real world and have made it (not quite) mandatory to find a solution outside the court system if at all possible. As of 29 April 2024, the new rules require every possible attempt to resolve issues by NCDR before resorting to the court. It’s not mandatory, but if you don’t try to keep it out of court for no good reason, then the court can penalise you with a costs order.
It is also a requirement before every hearing to provide the court with an update on what NCDR has been attempted.
Let me say here if you have a good reason then don’t panic. We can talk about that.
In this series of blogs we look at the various types of NCDR. This blog looks at Early Neutral evaluation.
Early Neutral evaluation
Early neutral evaluation is a non-binding form of dispute resolution. What you get is an initial “sense-check” from an expert independent third party. It is relatively new in family work, while it has been used commercially for many years.
The potential benefits of early Neutral Evaluation (ENE) are that you get a chance to know whether you are on the right track at a relatively early stage before huge sums of money are spent on legal fees, preparing all the evidence that may be needed at court. You are free to disregard anything said at an ENE, but you may find it helpful to focus the mind on the realities of litigation and the likelihood of success, therefore making it easier to reach a sensible settlement out of court.
Essentially, your solicitors will put together their own case summaries with brought details of the case and ask another expert, either an experienced family solicitor or barrister, to give their view on the direction this is likely to go. That way you have a roadmap and an overview of how to settle the case.
At this point, you may be inclined to ask, “Isn’t that what my solicitor is for?” Aren’t they supposed to give me the advice I need to put me on the right track? Family law is surprisingly complex; each case is unique, and the courts have wide discretion. Sometimes, two or even three heads are better than one. Your solicitor will only suggest it in cases where it will help in avoiding costly conflict.
Pros:
A good ENE will provide clarity and direction and ultimate saves time and costs.
Cons:
It often feels like an unnecessary expense. That is only a feeling.
The other articles in this series:
